Gotham FC and Seattle Reign criticize poor pitch conditions in NWSL playoff
HARRISON, N.J. β Gotham FC head coach Juan Carlos Amoros did not hold back in his criticism of the field conditions at Sports Illustrated Stadium following his team's narrow 1-0 victory over the Seattle Reign in the NWSL quarterfinals. His remarks underscored the ongoing infrastructure challenges that the league faces during its playoff season.
The NWSL had previously fined Gotham $10,000 due to the poor quality of the pitch, which had been heavily used in the weeks leading up to the match. Gotham, a secondary tenant at the stadium primarily used by MLS's New York Red Bulls, had to contend with a field that was still recovering from a rugby doubleheader held just a week prior. The Red Bulls played their regular season finale less than 24 hours before the NWSL match, further exacerbating the pitch's condition.
Gear for the Game
Sponsor success. Continue reading:
"I feel the obligation to almost apologize for the state of the pitch," Amoros stated after the match. "At this level, in this kind of game, as a league, we should be having a better surface. Unfortunately, our football club did absolutely everything in their power to make sure that was the case. Unfortunately, it wasn't, but luckily, it looks like nobody got hurt and the game was what it was."
Players from both teams expressed their concerns about the playing conditions. Gotham's Jaelin Howell, who returned from an ankle injury, noted the sandy and unstable surface but emphasized her commitment to the team. "Obviously it's pretty sandy out there and so a little unstable, but I want to be able to give my all to the team and everything I got," she said. "The other team has to play on that, too, so we acknowledged it and we moved on."
The Reign's Jess Fishlock, who played her final match of her career, was more blunt in her assessment. "We performed so well for this group of players to come against a team like that at home on this field, which is atrocious, just saying it out loud," she remarked. Her sentiments were echoed by Reign coach Laura Harvey, who has been involved with the league since its inception. "Let's be real, there's no way a playoff game should be played on that shit," she told ESPN post-match. "I just can't believe they've allowed it. They knew it last week."
Amoros acknowledged that the poor field conditions affected Gotham's performance. Despite winning, he described the match as "not the best football match that you will ever see." He explained that the players were forced to focus on the unpredictable nature of the pitch rather than their usual game plan. "When you play on a pitch like that, you cannot be thinking of the next action or what you're gonna do once you get that ball. You need to be looking at the ball because it can bounce at any given time," he said.
Gotham's struggles highlight deeper issues
Gotham will play their next match at Sports Illustrated Stadium against the Kansas City Current in the NWSL semifinals. Meanwhile, the Red Bulls, who missed the MLS Cup playoffs for the second consecutive season, will host a friendly against Club America the night before.
While the pitch presented challenges for both teams, Gotham's struggles extended beyond the field conditions. The reigning champions, who are favored to win the championship for the third time in four seasons, benefited from a fourth-minute own goal by Jordyn Bugg, but they failed to assert dominance throughout the match. Gotham did not register a single shot on target, with their six attempts totaling just 0.17 expected goals. In contrast, the Reign managed 11 shots and 0.54 expected goals, but were thwarted by Gotham's defense, including standout goalkeeper Ann-Katrin Berger.
"She literally does it on a consistent basis," said Jaedyn Shaw about Berger's performance. "It's crazy the kind of saves that she makes, and I think we're all really grateful to have her back there."
Gotham's attack, however, lacked the same effectiveness. Midfielder Rose Lavelle exited the match at halftime, managing her minutes after a recent injury, while forward Sam Kerr struggled to make an impact, failing to register a shot and only touching the ball 23 times in 90 minutes. Since joining Gotham in July, Kerr has scored just four goals in 18 games despite having 9.67 expected goals.
Reign's defense shines despite challenges
Amoros credited the Reign for their defensive efforts, noting their ability to disrupt Gotham's play. "I think they did a good job trying to stop certain situations," he said. "They were first and second in a lot of the duels, and they obviously play short passes to then go diagonal, which is something difficult to defend."
Shaw reflected on the team's performance, emphasizing the need for improvement. "I think we just need to be cleaner on the ball. Obviously, the surface doesn't really help, but just in general, I think we can be more comfortable on the ball, facing forward and just be clinical in our passes, which I think will help us get to the final third a little bit more with more quality chances on goal.





