Garrett Whitlock Open to Returning as Red Sox Starter Despite Bullpen Success
As the Boston Red Sox gear up for the playoffs, they boast one of the most formidable bullpens in Major League Baseball, largely thanks to the impressive performance of Garrett Whitlock. Once viewed as a potential starting pitcher, Whitlock's transition to the bullpen has been marked by dominance, yet he recently indicated a willingness to consider a return to starting, as reported by The Boston Globe.
"I definitely know my body better and know everything better now, and so itβs definitely something Iβd be open to. Will I?" Whitlock stated. "Iβm not going to walk into [chief baseball officer Craig Breslowβs] office and be like, βHey, Iβm starting.β So itβs one of those things where the team would have to be on board with it and just talk through everything and go through it. But itβs something Iβd always be open to."
Gear for the Game
Sponsor success. Continue reading:
Whitlock last started for the Red Sox in 2024, but since then, he has emerged as one of the league's top relievers. In the current season, he boasts an impressive 1.81 ERA, a 0.826 WHIP, and an average of 10.5 strikeouts per nine innings over 49.2 innings pitched. Despite his success, Whitlock remains realistic about the team's starting depth, noting, "I doubt Boston will do it. We’re pretty good on starting depth."
The decision to move Whitlock to the bullpen stemmed from concerns over his ability to handle the rigors of starting. Throughout his career, he has battled various injuries, including a right pec strain, hip issues, and elbow inflammation, culminating in a significant UCL injury that required an internal brace in 2024. While he has managed to stay healthier as a reliever, the Red Sox must weigh the benefits of his current role against the potential of his return to starting.
Lessons from fellow pitchers' transitions
Interestingly, Whitlock isn't alone in his journey. Seth Lugo of the Kansas City Royals recently made a similar switch back to starting and shared insights on the transition. "Once you make the switch back, you have the confidence. The problems you had earlier in your career, [which] sent you to the ’pen in the first place — you’re aware why those mistakes happened," Lugo explained.
Whitlock's relationship with other pitchers who have faced similar transitions has fostered camaraderie, as they often joke about their shared experiences. "We all joke that we’re all failed starters," he remarked, highlighting the unique challenges faced by pitchers navigating their roles.
In April 2022, the Red Sox extended Whitlock's contract, which is currently a four-year deal worth $18.75 million. However, as the contract nears its end, the Red Sox must consider their options: pick up his club options for 2027 and 2028, extend him further, or risk losing him to free agency. The upcoming collective bargaining agreement negotiations add another layer of complexity to these decisions.
Despite the uncertainty surrounding his future, Whitlock's value as a reliever is undeniable. Even with the potential for a starting role, his current contract options remain competitive within the league, making him an asset the Red Sox are unlikely to let slip away easily. As the team navigates these decisions, Whitlock's evolution as a pitcher will undoubtedly play a crucial role in shaping the Red Sox's pitching strategy moving forward.





