Mark Messier Critiques Oilers' Decision to Hire Mike Babcock
Mark Messier did not hold back his feelings regarding the Edmonton Oilers' recent decision to hire former Detroit Red Wings coach Mike Babcock. During ESPNβs NHL Opening Night media conference call, the Oilers legend expressed profound concern about Babcock's return to an NHL bench, a sentiment that resonated with many who remember Babcock's controversial tenure in Detroit.
"I am absolutely shocked they hired him," Messier stated, his disappointment evident. "Iβm absolutely shocked from the stories that I heard from very good, reputable, character people about the way they were treated." Messier's strong words reflect a broader unease within the hockey community regarding Babcock's past coaching methods, which have come under scrutiny from former players, particularly in light of allegations surrounding his treatment of Johan Franzen.
Gear for the Game
Sponsor success. Continue reading:
The Hall of Famer’s criticism extended beyond Babcock himself; he also raised questions about the Oilers' decision-making process, particularly the involvement of players in the interview process for the coaching position. Messier warned that such involvement could blur the lines between management and players, complicating the team's structure and dynamics.
Babcock, who coached the Red Wings from 2005 to 2015 and led them to a Stanley Cup victory in 2008, has a legacy that is now marred by serious criticisms from former players. Nicklas Lidstrom, another Red Wings legend, has previously described Babcock as a demanding coach, shedding light on the mixed feelings surrounding his leadership style.
Differing views on Babcock's impact
In contrast to Messier's alarm, fellow analyst Ray Ferraro offered a more measured perspective on Babcock's hiring. While he acknowledged the surprise at the decision, Ferraro focused on the potential benefits Babcock could bring to the Oilers. "Nobody will have a question about what their role is or what they’re supposed to do," Ferraro noted, emphasizing Babcock's reputation for being organized and direct.
Ferraro's analysis suggests that while Babcock's methods may be polarizing, his clarity and structure could provide the Oilers with the guidance they need to succeed. However, he also recognized the inherent risks involved, particularly given the mixed reviews from former players regarding their experiences with Babcock.
The contrasting views of Messier and Ferraro encapsulate the tension surrounding Babcock's hiring. Messier sees a troubling decision rooted in past player treatment, while Ferraro views a coach who could potentially bring much-needed organization to the Oilers. As the season unfolds, the implications of this hiring will undoubtedly be scrutinized, with both the players and management facing the consequences of their choices.





