Finebaum Questions Notre Dame's Playoff Worthiness Ahead of Miami Clash
As the college football season progresses, the stakes are rising for the Notre Dame Fighting Irish, currently sitting at 7-1 and ranked No. 4 in the nation. However, ESPN and SEC Network host Paul Finebaum is skeptical about their playoff credentials. On a recent episode of The Matt Barrie Show, Finebaum stated that Notre Dame has "no business" being in the College Football Playoff unless they can secure a victory in their crucial upcoming game against No. 1 Miami. This matchup, set to take place in South Bend, is particularly significant as Miami was the team that denied Notre Dame a playoff spot last season.
Finebaum's critique centers on the quality of Notre Dame's schedule rather than their impressive record. Despite finishing last season with a 10-2 record and winning their last ten games, the Fighting Irish were left out of the playoffs, finishing at No. 11. Miami claimed the last at-large bid after defeating Notre Dame 27-24 in a head-to-head matchup. This year, while Notre Dame boasts an impressive average of 40.3 points scored per game and only 13.4 points allowed, Finebaum argues that their schedule has not posed enough of a challenge.
Gear for the Game
Sponsor success. Continue reading:
"But Notre Dame is the one everyone will be watching this week," Finebaum remarked, highlighting the significance of the Miami game. He noted that if Notre Dame loses, their playoff hopes would be severely diminished, especially in light of the tumultuous landscape of college football this season. With seven AP Top 25 teams suffering losses recently, including Ohio State, the door is slightly ajar for a 10-2 team to sneak into the playoffs. However, Finebaum maintains that without a significant win, Notre Dame's chances remain slim.
The debate surrounding Notre Dame's playoff eligibility is further complicated by the fact that they have a safety net this year: an agreement with the playoff committee that guarantees them a spot if they finish in the top 12 of the final rankings. This provision could play a crucial role in their postseason aspirations, but it does not absolve them of the need to prove themselves against top-tier opponents.
Finebaum critiques Notre Dame's inconsistency
Finebaum did not spare Miami from criticism either. The Hurricanes, currently undefeated at 8-0 after a narrow victory over North Carolina, are averaging an impressive 49 points per game. Meanwhile, Notre Dame's recent performance against Navy, where they won 35-13 but struggled at times, raises questions about their readiness for the challenge ahead. The Fighting Irish trailed at halftime and only managed to pull away in the second half, which Finebaum suggests is indicative of their inconsistency.
Notre Dame faces crucial playoff test against Miami
As the matchup approaches, the pressure mounts for Notre Dame. Their best win this season came against Wisconsin, but with the Badgers recently falling out of the rankings after a heavy loss, that victory loses some of its luster. Upcoming games against Boston College, SMU, and Syracuse do not present significant opportunities to bolster their playoff resume either.
The showdown against Miami is not just another game; it is a litmus test for Notre Dame's playoff aspirations. With both teams boasting strong offensive and defensive statistics, the outcome will likely have significant implications for the College Football Playoff picture. As Finebaum aptly puts it, if Notre Dame cannot secure a win in this marquee matchup, their playoff hopes may very well evaporate, leaving fans and analysts alike to ponder what could have been.





